Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?

giovedì, 17 luglio 2008 12.03 by Marco Bellinaso

Un mio amico ha un blog piuttosto conosciuto, Il Burbero Scontroso, dove da quasi 3 anni parla di politica, cultura, società, tv e cinema, letteratura e sport. Essendo un ateo fiero e convinto, il Burbero tempo fa ha creato il "Papabanner", un bannerino con una piccola foto di Papa Ratzinger e la scritta "Il papa scomunica questo blog". Il burbero invitava i suoi lettori a copiare il codice HTML per inserire il banner nel proprio blog, perchè (cit.) "E' tempo di distiguersi, di esigere la dignità che le posizioni agnostiche, ateistiche, relativiste e progressiste meritano". Da allora, ben più di 500 blogger hanno applicato il banner.

E' notizia di oggi che il Burbero è stato denunciato a causa del Papabanner, e che la Polizia Postale ha fatto immediatamente rimuovere il banner dal server di hosting. Ora, indipendentemente da ciò che ognuno possa pensare del Papabanner (una cretinata? un bannerino simpatico? un'offesa per chi è credente? una stupidaggine, ma senza valore e senza danno per alcuno?), e dal fatto che si sia o meno credenti, quello che è successo è abbastanza sconvolgente.

Basta che una qualunque persona denunci un sito, adducendo una qualsiasi motivazione, perchè questo venga immediatamente oscurato? Non ci deve essere un giudice che giudica e spiega i motivi (possibilmente anche al diretto interessato) della decisione? E' motivo sufficiente il fatto che una persona si senta offesa da quanto scritto su un sito? E se qualcuno si sentisse offeso dal sito del Vaticano? Sarebbe accaduto lo stesso se l'argomento non fosse stata la religione, ma qualcosa di più "frivolo"?

Ci sarebbero molte altre domande, ma la principale è: dov'è la libertà di espressione in Italia, se vengono oscurati anche contenuti totalmente innocui di questo tipo?

Va bene che l'Italia è un paese cattolico, ma essere cattolici è sinonimo di essere bigotti e intolleranti verso le opinioni altrui? (peraltro espresse abbastanza educatamente, a differenza dei commenti offensivi ricevuti da molti anti-banner che si credono religiosi). Io non lo credo, conosco moltissime persone molto credenti ma perfettamente in grado di discutere in modo estremamente civile con chi ha opinioni religiose diametralmente opposte. Purtroppo però non tutti sono abbastanza intelligenti e tolleranti da accettare le opinioni altrui - questo va anche bene finchè queste persone si limitano a dissentire e a non accettare la discussione...ma quando riescono addirittura a limitare la libertà altrui, la cosa diventa davvero preoccupante e inaccettabile.

Il Burbero è attualmente all'opera per capire cosa può fare...vedremo... 

Correntemente valutato 4.6 da 12 utenti

  • Currently 4,583333/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Segnala:  
Tags:  
Categorie:   Personale
Azioni:   E-mail | Permalink | Commenti (70) | RSS CommentiRSS comment feed

Post correlati

Commenti

luglio 17. 2008 13.45

giadatea

hei, l'ho visto quel banner in giro, molti miei amici ce l'avevano e trovo assurdo sapere che sia stato bannato..... di al burbero di fare subito il papabannedbanner o come si chiama, insomma, un nuovo banner che parli anche di questa censura

giadatea

luglio 17. 2008 14.01

speech

Povera Italia in balia del bigottismo...
Avete tutto il mio appoggio.

speech

luglio 17. 2008 15.53

Uakko

L'italia è un paese laico!

Uakko

luglio 17. 2008 15.58

Marco Bellinaso

>> L'italia è un paese laico!

Non si direbbe, almeno a giudicare dal peso della Chiesa nella politica del nostro paese...

Comunque, intendevo che il Cristianesimo/Cattolicesimo sono la religione/confessione principale in Italia...

Marco Bellinaso

luglio 17. 2008 16.28

federico

Secondo me voi condondete lo Stato con il Paese. L'Italia è uno Stato laico, sì...ma è anche un Paese cattolico. E su questo non ci sono dubbi.

federico

luglio 17. 2008 16.36

marcello

perché scandalizzarsi? in italia la libertà di espressione non sappiamo neanche cos'è! e questo non oggi, ma secoli secoli secoli addietro. purtroppo in italia abbiamo il papa e, come già machiavelli diceva, è il motivo di tanta decadenza... il fatto è che ai politici del papa non interessa un emerito c.... ma è un enorme serbatoio di voti. spero nelle nuove generazioni. prima o poi il potere spiri-temporale finirà... pace e fraternità...

marcello

luglio 17. 2008 16.45

marco

Fosse solo questo, sarebbe fastidioso ma chissenefrega, il problema vero é che questa mentalità del "io stabilisco le regole, poi accuso, poi giudico e poi agisco" si diffonde, tutte le varie Autorità ( comunicazioni, energia, privacy ecc. ) funzionano così. E nessuno si lamenta del fatto che la Costituzione non le prevede e che violano il principio, quello sì espresso, dellaseparazione dei poteri. Altro che indipendenza della magistratura !!!

marco

luglio 17. 2008 19.00

libero

stiamo diventando peggio degli estremisti islamici!
ITALIA,ADESSO SI'CHE SEI IN GINOCCHIO!
SVEGLIATI,ITALIA!

libero

luglio 17. 2008 19.32

erere

hanno fatto bene, dovevano anche venire a casa vostra e arrestarvi e una settimana di carcere o multa salata. viva il Papa e la Chiesa e grande Silvio

erere

agosto 4. 2008 14.32

viviana

non lo sapevo: ho visto in giro il banner e l'ho trovato carino (e sacrosanto!), se non l'ho aggiunto al mio sito è solo perché ne avevo già due in sostegno del laicismo e direi che il messaggio arrivava già forte e chiaro...
ma adesso forse la migliore risposta sarebbe che i 500 blogger diventassero 2000!

viviana

dicembre 6. 2009 03.46

fast payday loans

Interesting article. Were did you got all the information from? Anyway thank you for this great post!

fast payday loans

dicembre 7. 2009 22.16

buy now

Looking forward for more such stuff. Loved your style of providing the information and the nature of the content.

buy now

dicembre 28. 2009 09.30

payday loans

Interesting ... as always - is your blog making any cash advance ? ;)

payday loans

dicembre 30. 2009 02.15

Minnesota Payday Loans

Do you have any more info on this?

Minnesota Payday Loans

gennaio 3. 2010 15.27

payday loans

You made some good points there. I searched this topic and found out that most people will agree with your blog.

payday loans

gennaio 10. 2010 00.45

goutal perfume

Thanks for this great post. I have implemented it like your post says.

goutal perfume

gennaio 10. 2010 20.39

plus size womens dress

Very good and detailed post there OP. Apprecaiate the time you put into this.

plus size womens dress

gennaio 12. 2010 12.54

personal trainers gold coast

Before a series, St. Louis manager Frankie Frisch instructed his pitching staff to avoid throwing Brooklyn's Tony Cuccinello a fastball.

Dizzy Dean objected. "He can't hit my fastball."

He begged Frisch to let him throw Cuccinello a fastball. Frisch refused. Finally with the game in hand, he relented. Dean threw Cuccinello a fastball. Cuccinello hit it out of the park.

Dean turned to Frisch. "By gosh, Frankie. You were right for once."





Regards
Hillard




personal trainers gold coast

gennaio 18. 2010 07.40

recycled plastic outdoor furniture

A young boy and his doting grandmother were walking along the sea shore when a huge wave appeared out of nowhere, sweeping the child out to sea. The horrified woman fell to her knees, raised her eyes to the heavens and begged the Lord to return her beloved grandson. And, another wave reared up and deposited the stunned child on the sand. The grandmother looked the boy over carefully. He was fine.

But still she stared up angrily toward the heavens. "When we came," she snapped indignantly, "he had a hat!"





Regards
Hardesty



recycled plastic outdoor furniture

gennaio 21. 2010 08.56

watch smallville season 7

A salesman dropped in to see a business customer. Not a soul was in the office
except a big dog emptying wastebaskets. The salesman stared at the animal, wondering if
his imagination could be playing tricks on him. The dog looked up and said, Don't be surprised. This is just part of my job.

Incredible! exclaimed the man. I can't believe it! Does your boss know what a prize he has in you? An animal that can talk!

No, no, pleaded the dog. Please don't! If he finds out I can talk, he'll make me answer the phone as well!



Regards
Davidson


watch smallville season 7

febbraio 13. 2010 11.08

teeth whitening reviews

That is some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to offer such helpful information here.

teeth whitening reviews

febbraio 16. 2010 14.58

Herbal colon cleanse

In searching for sites related to web hosting and specifically comparison hosting linux plan web, your site came up.You are a very smart person!

Herbal colon cleanse

febbraio 18. 2010 14.45

cinsellik

Thanks for good information.

cinsellik

febbraio 18. 2010 22.29

ssk sorgulama

i love to read articles that are informative and beneficial in nature.

ssk sorgulama

febbraio 19. 2010 16.06

loeffler randall aspen

Great article I will link to it from my loeffler randall aspen website. Thank you.

loeffler randall aspen

febbraio 21. 2010 01.17

ehliyet

I really enjoyed read your article, very interesting ...

ehliyet

febbraio 22. 2010 11.59

Acne scar treatment

Hi there, I found your blog via Google while searching for first aid for a heart attack and your post looks very interesting for me.

Acne scar treatment

febbraio 22. 2010 15.01

bağkur

nice template and great article.thanks this is great information.

bağkur

febbraio 23. 2010 14.08

marco

beh io penso che ognuno possa esprimere il suo parere però senza discriminare altri con banner pubblicitari di questo tipo...

marco

febbraio 27. 2010 19.43

personal loans

As a Noob, I am always seeking online for articles that can help me. Thank you

personal loans

marzo 5. 2010 04.49

watch the pacific online

Hello.Forgive me if my english language is not nice.anyway i just intend to tell i like this article a lot. thank you!

watch the pacific online

marzo 6. 2010 16.22

instant loans

You made some good points there. I searched this topic and found out that most people will agree with your blog. Big thanks for the useful info i found on Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?.

instant loans

marzo 9. 2010 09.13

replica watches

thanks for the share

replica watches

marzo 9. 2010 10.51

replica watches

thanks for the share

replica watches

marzo 10. 2010 11.22

bad credit loans

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article. Big thanks for the useful info i found on Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?.

bad credit loans

marzo 15. 2010 13.14

Stretch marks treatment

As a Noob, I am always seeking online for articles that can help me. Thank you

Stretch marks treatment

marzo 19. 2010 03.21

north carolina furniture

This is a very informative post! I usually do not reply but in this case you deserve it.

north carolina furniture

marzo 19. 2010 10.30

rolex replica

thank you very much for sharing this article!

rolex replica

marzo 20. 2010 07.32

spray on tanning

Advantageously, the post is actually the sweetest on this noteworthy topic. I agree with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your incoming updates. Just saying thanks will not just be enough, for the wonderful lucidity in your writing. I will directly grab your rss feed to stay abreast of any updates. Fabulous work and much success in your business efforts! spray on tanning review

spray on tanning

marzo 22. 2010 22.19

genital wart removal

I don’t usually reply to posts but I will in this case. WoW Smile Big thanks for the useful info i found on Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?.

genital wart removal

marzo 23. 2010 16.23

ehliyet

Aw, this was a really quality post. In theory I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real effort to make a good article... but what can I say... I procrastinate alot and never seem to get something done.

ehliyet

marzo 24. 2010 15.04

rolex replica

thank you

rolex replica

marzo 24. 2010 16.41

debt settlement services

Hello. Great job. I did not expect this on a Wednesday. This is a good story. Thanks!

debt settlement services

marzo 25. 2010 13.57

Foods That Get Rid Of Gout

You will discover certainly a great deal of details like that to take into consideration. That may be a wonderful stage to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly you will discover questions like the a single you bring up where probably the most essential point are going to be functioning in honest great faith. I don?t know if best practices have emerged around issues like that, but I'm sure that your job is clearly identified as being a fair game.

Foods That Get Rid Of Gout

marzo 25. 2010 15.00

bağkur

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post

bağkur

marzo 27. 2010 10.15

supplemental dental insurance

Just desire to say your post is brilliant. The clarity with your submit is purely impressive and i can assume you might be an expert on this topic. Well with your permission allow me to grab your rss feed to hold as much as date with succeeding post. Thanks a million and please preserve up the strong work.

supplemental dental insurance

marzo 29. 2010 03.19

funny jokes

<a href="http://www.funnyjokesz.com/">funny jokes</a>

funny jokes

marzo 29. 2010 21.39

arac sorgulama

I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. I am quite sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!

arac sorgulama

marzo 29. 2010 22.40

treatment for toenail fungus

Finally, got what I was looking for!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. Glad I stumbled into this article! smile I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. Big thanks for the useful info i found on Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?.

treatment for toenail fungus

marzo 30. 2010 03.23

Mens Engagement Rings

Hi there, Im at my job and was browsing within the web, goofing off, when I came around your website. It's very nicely executed, and I definitely like your mode of composing.

Mens Engagement Rings

marzo 30. 2010 05.58

hp inkjet cartridges

Hi I determined this internet site by mistake when i was looking Google for this acne issue, I have to say your website is truly helpful I also adore the theme, its incredible!. I dont have that a lot time to read all your submit at the moment but I have bookmarked your web page and also signed up for your personal RSS feeds. I'll be again in a day or two. many thanks for a wonderful website.

hp inkjet cartridges

marzo 30. 2010 14.03

dirt cheap rims

I was searching for this facts since a long time. You've truly completed my search by posting this right here. It will proven to be extremely helpful for me

dirt cheap rims

marzo 30. 2010 21.38

rims for cheap

Hi I determined this internet site by mistake when i was looking Google for this acne issue, I have to say your website is truly helpful I also adore the theme, its incredible!. I dont have that a lot time to read all your submit at the moment but I have bookmarked your web page and also signed up for your personal RSS feeds. I'll be again in a day or two. many thanks for a wonderful website.

rims for cheap

marzo 31. 2010 12.32

Los Angeles Internet Marketing

lo Stato con il Paese. L'Italia è uno Stato laico, sì...ma è anche un Paese cattolico. E su questo non ci sono dubbi.

Los Angeles Internet Marketing

aprile 3. 2010 10.01

 escorts sydney

I wanted to thank you for this great read!

escorts sydney

aprile 4. 2010 16.54

cheap car loans

There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also.

cheap car loans

aprile 5. 2010 11.20

1 800 pets

Happ Easter people, have a good one.

1 800 pets

aprile 6. 2010 19.35

van vehicles leasing

I wouldn't hope to much of getting the result overturned and the ban lifted, religion is a very touchy subject.

van vehicles leasing

aprile 8. 2010 02.18

Aquamarine Engagement Rings

I wanted to say that it is nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same data elsewhere. This was the very first place that told me the answer. Big many thanks with the practical info i found on Primer submit.

Aquamarine Engagement Rings

aprile 8. 2010 02.18

Pink Engagement Rings

I was seeking crucial facts on this subject matter. The information was critical as I'm about to launch my personal portal. Thanks for providing a missing link in my business.

Pink Engagement Rings

aprile 8. 2010 02.56

 telecharger sonnerie gratuite

Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. It contains truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing. Looking forward to more!

telecharger sonnerie gratuite

aprile 10. 2010 03.22

how to get abs fast

I'm not a lot of a guy who thinks in so deeply about internet design but I think your submit had some valid points in it. Like designers are forced to design stuff for the limited code available and not go beyond it, their innovation is somewhat limited but still I consider Online Style won't die! I agree that Amazon and other some big sites won't have a weblog but now a days it's extremely essential to have some sort of option available so people can quickly communicate their thoughts. I believe Amazon if wants to shift it to that, they can get a customized CMS for themselves.

how to get abs fast

aprile 10. 2010 14.34

milly designer clothes

Interesting perspective, not one i share though.

milly designer clothes

aprile 10. 2010 17.10

digest it

It is a fine thing to have ability, but the ability to discover ability in others is the true test.

digest it

aprile 10. 2010 23.14

tunes

Radically good post.

tunes

aprile 12. 2010 04.05

Self Employed Dental Insurance

Hi, I discovered your internet site whilst browsing searching for anything entertaining to examine. It's enough to say, I've observed it! I'll certainly be coming back to go through more. Thanks again for taking the work to create all this

Self Employed Dental Insurance

aprile 12. 2010 09.34

how to repair your credit history

I completely agree with the above comment, the web is with a doubt growing into one of the most critical medium of communication all around the globe and its due to sites like this that ideas are spreading so quickly.

how to repair your credit history

aprile 13. 2010 20.30

new cellulite treatment

Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch! Big thanks for the useful info i found on Libertà di espressione in Italia...dov'è?.

new cellulite treatment

aprile 14. 2010 06.51

portfolio lighting

this is a splendid post and I would give a five out of five rating to it. Need some more posts like this to be done. Thank you and looking for more of this kind. Pls drop by my portfolio lighting review site.

portfolio lighting

aprile 15. 2010 13.35

flex programming

Hoping for a good change, that would be great if you could provide me with plugins from your blog.

flex programming

Commenti chiusi